Carrie is so beautiful!And she has an amazing voice. That picture doesn't even look like Kellie! I'm sorry but Kellie can keep trying all she wants, she will never look good, and she will never be able to sing! That's why she LOST on American Idol. Who ever said Kellie is a better singer then Carrie needs major help! I think that Kellie needs to give up! Go away Kellie! you will never be as good as Carrie! Of course all of the awards Carrie has already won proves it!

They are both beautiful girls... My vote is for Kellie because she really dressed up for the awards.. Carrie looked pretty too but her dress looked more like a dressy sun dress.

I thought Kellie looked amazing/stunning....really dressed for the occasion. Carrie is a very pretty girl and could have looked stunning too if she had dressed for the occasion.

KELLIE.. KELLIE, KELLIE.. IS IT!! LOL CARRIE LOOKS LIKE SHE TOOK AN OLD COUCH FROM THE 70'S CUT IT UP AND WORE IT!

LMAO.. OMG..

KELLIE TOTALLY HAS THE WHOLE PACKAGE. THIS POLL IS.. ((BLEEEPPPPPP))

Carrie has a management team that tries to make her look good and still still ends up looking like trash.

Kellie has a management team that is trying to make Kellie look bad and she still ends up looking good.

The thing is both had the same management team, none other than 19 Entertainment, which by the way runs American Idol. Seems management has gone out of their way at underpromoting Kellie in hopes that she doesn't outshine the one that they have been overpromoting. I wonder when they will realize it's a waste of time trying to manipulate public opinion and start promoting the one that the public really wants, that being Kellie Pickler.

I guess management can't handle the fact that they backed a loser to begin with as the public still hasn't taken a liking to their boring Carrie Underwood. (Sorry Simon, she may have sold more than any other Idol contestant, but it was only through manipulation of promotion on Sony/BMG's part who owns all the Idols labels, not because her and her album are any good, I should know, I was one of those that got suckered into buying the piece of crap Cd of hers).

As for Kellie, her personality still shines far above the likes of Carrie, and Kellie's album blows Carrie's away in comparison, and it's only a matter of time before the public finds out both. Management may try to hide the fact that Kellie hasn't changed her appearance at all, as anyone can see in her recent appearances including the ACM Award show, but the truth will come out and I'm afraid both Carrie and management are going to be the ones that suffer the wrath of their manipulation.

Because while Kellie is gaining new fans, it is Idol's ratings that are down, just like the AMC's Award show rating were down, and it's Sony/BMG's albums sales that are down.

If they keep this up they will be the ones that continue to suffer, not Kellie, because the public knows which talent entertains them, and that is none other than Kellie Dawn Pickler.

i couldn't even tell that was kelly.

I don't understand how those who "claim" to know Carrie are spitting her name. Are you kidding me? I had a friend tip me off to this poll after seeing it on her fan club. I've known Carrie for years. She is still the sweet, humble, and grateful person she has always been. Her confidence level has grown, but it needed to. Carrie has always been very insecure of herself, and because of the out pouring of love and appreciation of what she does and who she is has helped her overcome that. I don't understand how cruel people can be while sitting behind a computer screen. Grow up, please. Carrie is sensational and she is loved by so many. People who knew her before, and after. Not to mention the millions of fans she has standing behind her. Maybe that's what you don't like. The support that she has. Reality check, Carrie's outstanding. Deal with it.

All you Kelbot haters need to crawl back under the Rock you came from.

Loser comments from losers!

I hate country music but they are both pretty. carrie looks better though. kellie does look nice though.

That does not look like Kellie

I have always said that becoming famous is the best revenge. So all of you out there who like calling me names I am still famous and you are still sitting at your computers thinking of things to say to trash me. I will still be famous tomorrow and you will still be losers.

I tend to believe the people who say that Carrie has a bad persoanlity, maybe they really do know who she really was before she got famous, and I think some people on here really do know her on a more personal level.

I don't understand why everyone has to be so mean to Carrie, she seems like a ery sweet girl and she doesn't look to skinny. These people who say they went to college with her and say she is so mean and snooty, try looking at yourself instead of talking trash about other people who you most likely DON'T KNOW!!!!! I liked Kellie on American Idol, but now I think she looks to made up. Just my opinion.

You may have met the sweet fake Carrie, but those of us who know her from her college days know that she is not sweet or nice. She is a rude snotty girl who is very ungrateful for her fame. Many of us voted for her too, and how did she thank us, she gave us all the big blow off.
We still love to listen to her sing, but we know that she was never our friend she just needed the votes to win AI. So this is my opinion of her because I too have met this selfish girl, and I don't know her anymore now than I did 2 years ago.

I think that they both look gorgeous..but I voted for Carrie =) Loved her performance that night!