Hahahahaha. Don't you people realise it's a singing competition. In other words, the final three should've been Melinda, Lakisha and Jordin. Blake sounds average, and at time's a little bit inexperienced. Simon was right, Jordin wiped the floor with him. Thank goodness Blake didn't win, that would've been the third injustice on the show. Overall best vocalist- Melinda, who showed power, great control and technique, the powerhouse would be Lakisha, and the best recording voice would be with Jordin. Since it's a singing competition, Melinda should've won. But meh, at least Jordin took it out in the end.

This guy is a star. Why is he on this show? He'll be the one from this season to sell millions, win or lose. Vote for him, if he doesn't win he's going to pull a Daughtry and embarass those who outlast him.

First of all, Blake with dark hair = HOT!!! Blonde looks good, but the dark hair did some unexpected things to me. Blake's in it to win it and I sincerely hope that he does. His rendition of this song kicked serious butt and took plenty of names. I actually disliked my second favorite's(Jordin) performance the least. I'm not feeling the whole comment about Lakisha. "I bet if they would of named some rapper she would of known his music." Sounds a TAD bit racist to me. I love Lakisha! She doesn't sing my kind of music, but she does have an amazing voice and personality wise she's awesome.

I loved Blake Lewis version on Bon Jovi's song. It was very orginal and not boring like the rest. On another note I do agree with what another person comented here earlier about booting out Lakisha, Melinda, and Jordin. Those three women are to gospil and all you really here out of there mouth as yelling and over doing it. I don't really here the meaning or true feeling of the song because they are so predictable. Oh! and when I found out Lakisha didn't know of Bon Jovi's music!...Where has she been? I bet if they would of named some rapper she would of known his music. Thats just sad...if you want to be in the music business you need to know your artist in all areas! PLEASE DON'T VOTE FOR LAKISHA, MELINDA, OR JORDING THEY SUCK AND ARE BORING!

I really don't care who goes home tonight as long as it is not Blake. And maybe Jordin can stay too?? And Blake please go back to blonde, it's summer time and looks good!

It's time for Phil and Chris to go home. Chris is a Justin Timberlake wannabe. Although, I'm not too crazy about Lakisha. She's so bland, no personality!!

I absolutely loved EVERYTHING bout Blake's performance last night.. Even the HAIR! hehe!
I think it was the best song all night, if not in all the seasons of AI. def the most original. I think Jordin, should've sang "who said you can't go home" since it's a slower song, and I think she would've done a better job at it.

xx

kc, Phil creeps me out too! Something about his eyes, smile, the whole look! *shudder*

I think Blake's performance last night was the best that has ever been shown on American Idol. It really showed his versatility. Melinda and Lakisha are just like the girl who was in Dreamgirls

No seriously he was up there doing things that people do with beat machines... get a clue Blake!

12:40 PM Blakeiscrazy IS CRAZY!!!!!!!!!!! blake rocks!!!!! however, i do think that phil looks like an alien and should go home. but i think chris should go home too.

I think it is hilarious how some just love to hate Blake Lewis. He is by far the most talented contestant we've really ever seen on the show. I was simply in awe when he performed last night, I thought he did an incredible job with the spread. Jon Bon Jovi didn't really seem to like what he did with the song during the critique, but the boy made the song his own. He didn't destroy the "classic rock song" anymore than Jordin killed the absolute greatest Bon Jovi song ever, come on! She could have picked one of his slower ballads and did an incredible job. To the question about who's going home tonight, I'm going to say Chris and Lakisha. She had horrible performances for the past month up till last night, but I think it was a little too late. I'm thinking either Blake and Jordin or Melinda and Jordin in the final two, but I agree that Blake would be better off venturing off on his own like Chris Daughtry.

Now that they are at final 6 they all have a good chance at making it in the future. Granted, there is only 1 American idol winner, but that hadn't stopped some runner-ups or other finalists in getting record deals and making a name. Kelly and Carrie are the ones that did best, but the others did make a mark too. Look at last years finalists, McFee and Daughtry are doing much better than Taylor really did/is.
Blake is good and different from the other finalists in that he is more creative. He's not such a good singer, compared to the rest of them he's mediocre, but he makes good arrangements to old tunes and puts a spin on them then sells the package. He will have success in life. He seems more cocky than he is, he is just as nervous as the others when the judges pass their judgement, he just shows it differently.
Melinda is a pro and she as consistently managed to adapt to all genres of music thrown at her. Even is she doesn't win, she will make it in the business.
Lakisha and Jordin are both good singers and they will get better with age and both should find a niche.
Chris and Phil can both sing, but there is something missing that will not take either of them to the winner's podium. Chris sounds to boy-bandish and Phil needs better stage presence and to tone down his big voice sometimes.
Of all of them, Blake and Jordin have the package that can be referred to as "American Idol" and for that stand the best chance of winning it while the others, although some much better performaners, don't have that AI package.

I have to say Blake was pretty brave and I give him credit for that but I didn't like his performance last night. However, I still think he has every right to be in the Top4. Jordin is my favorite and I didn't think last night was THAT bad, obviously not great, but not painful to listen to (like Sanjaya!). Her advantage over the other 2 powerful women is that she has wider appeal and a more saleable sound than LaKisha or Melinda. Since last week's votes are going to be added to, I think Phil and Chris are going home and I will NOT miss Phil's creepy camera stares or Chris's weird eyebrow raises.

Oh I loved Chris, he shouldn't go home. I don't like Blake but he did Rock last night he was awesome. I like LaKisha she just doesn't have the IDOL look. It will be Phil and LaKisha going home tonight. Look at the only two Idols that made it big. Kelly and Carrie, you have to have the whole package, you have to be able to sing but have to have the look too, shouldn't be that way but it is.

I think Chris is really good. Blake, is good just seems to be cocky. Melinda is awesome too just don't think she has the selling power like Carrie and Kelly did. Chris or Blake would. They have the look too, that makes certain Idol stars go big. Even Chris Daughtery and Katherine McPhee did better than Taylor, they too have the look and voice that sell.